A Reflection on Islene Pinder's Fascination with Neutral Tension Flow by Ling Ong. March 13, 2019

BALAM is in the Merriam-Webster; it is our company name, but the dictionary says it is the Mayan deity of agriculture who has a long head, a nocturnal supernatural who whistles as he walks on air.  For us though, BALAM is the Balinese American Dance Theatre and represents a blend of Balinese and American aesthetics.  We are also inspired by the European Baroque, Spanish, Japanese Noh, and those dance traditions are very likely to appear in our performances.  We are drawn to diverse movement-techniques, and we do not recoil from the European thought-patterns so deeply ingrained in our bodies such that an easy walk across the floor turns into a long and winding assessment of Effort-Shape, positioning in space-near and far; the Balinese taksu that is a spiritual stage-presence; the problem of reconciling the energy of balletic, athletic partnering with the Balinese dancing face of discreet smiles and flickering eyes.

The work of movement analysts and therapists, who were actively promoting the principles of Rudolf Laban and embellishing upon his methods of analysis and notation, profoundly influenced BALAM’s founder, Islene Pinder.   She truly enjoyed their pointillist reduction as a method of self-comprehension, whether in the everyday or theatrical context.  Converting their weighty analysis into her own appreciation of each dancer’s Effort-Shape patterns and idiosyncratic style, Islene practiced “on the body” choreography as the pathway for Balinese movements to come to the professional modern-dancer. 

Of all the Laban-influenced concepts Islene loved discussing, Neutral Flow seemed the most important to her.  It is best understood as existing in between Free and Bound Flow on the Tension Flow Scale.  She saw how slight moments of Neutral Tension Flow in the Balinese dancer’s movements were contrasting and thus accentuating the movements gravitating between Bound Tension Flow and Free Tension Flow.  She associated Tension Flows with elasticity and the regulation of continuity and discontinuity in movement.  So she was fascinated by how the child, learning to master his/her small body in the world, inevitably is resolving “the great internal affair of the temperament and feelings, matters of safety versus danger, feeling tones and needs”; and the child’s personal patterns of resolution would come forth as “rhythms of Tension Flow (which) would become appropriate to specific tasks and become functional” such that we shall see “rhythms of excitation, gratification, and relaxation” as the “child achieves mastery over initiation, continuity and stoppage.”  For Islene, Laban’s Effort was clearly impossible without the underlying rhythms of Tension Flow which “reflect our bodily needs and…are guided by our wishes”, and once those rhythms become “preferred patterns of tension-flow”, they become “the substrate of a person’s temperament”.  In her personal notes, Islene kept a yellowed, typed cribsheet of these important statements; these pearls of wisdom influenced the way she interacted with students and professional dancers.

Neutral Tension Flow was a concept originally developed by Dr. Judith Kestenberg (http://www.kestenbergmovementprofile.org/home.htm).  Dr. Kestenberg formulated the Kestenberg Movement Profile as a method for analyzing and notating the interactions of mother and child, those non-verbal expressions beginning in the womb.  Muscle lacking tension and being in a state of de- animation was an essential factor for describing the inter-personal dynamics of the unborn child’s and the mother’s physicalities.
I like to think that Islene may have associated Neutral Flow with floating in water or the fact that once upon a time, in the 1960s or 1970s, she was in a New York University workshop that involved standing still on demi-pointe for long periods of time, say up to 45 minutes or so.  Islene laughed over the memory of her reflex reaction—hopping around like a kangaroo—when the instructor told the students to let go.  Was he the legendary Alan Wayne attempting to induce the sensation of Neutral Flow through prolonged static posture?  There is the Alan Wayne Technique that trains the body to move with subtle expressions by totally exhausting the larger muscular parts; but having never experienced this technique, I wonder how it recruits all the soft tissues—muscles, tendons, ligaments, fascia—whether in tandem or altogether in unison.

There is the biomechanical fact that a kangaroo can bounce with minimal muscular effort in its lower legs when the soft tissues are acting like springs receiving/releasing kinetic energy.   We can relish the divine playfulness as we follow that kangaroo bouncing down a laboratory treadmill; it is needing less and less oxygen as it gains speed, rebounding into longer hops.  We can only wonder if the kangaroo’s lower legs ever have moments of Neutral Flow and if such moments drag upon velocity because the scientists recorded a higher rate of oxygen consumption when the kangaroo was ambling along upon 4 limbs and a tail.  [Dawson, T.J., and Taylor, C.R. (1973) Energetic cost of locomotion in kangaroos. Nature, Lond. 246:313-314.]
Carlos Fittante has had tinier releases of Neutral Flow performing European Baroque dance.  In his opinion, aristocratic courtiers would have resorted to Neutral Flow as they stood for hours (chairs were the privilege of the royal family), backs against the wall and supported by stiff corsets (worn by women and elderly men), dozing off as they waited for an audience with the king.  His picture of subliminal, fatigued anticipation is actually based upon historical documentation of court protocol, so we may reasonably suppose a great deal of genteel de-animation, tempered by courtly self-control, transformed into moments of stillness as self-preparation.

I saw the white-gloved hands of Carlos, who danced a Baroque chaconne to music composed by Jean-Baptiste Lully--a favorite of France’s Sun King, Louis XIV.  His white-gloved hands were larger than life as they vividly put into motion the Baroque sentiments eloquently interpreted by the Hartford Symphony Orchestra.  I saw momentary points of Neutral Flow contrasting and thus emphasizing whorls, flicks, commands and rhetorical flourishes of hands and wrists, all necessary to offset the heaviness of the court costume and tall, plumed headdress.

Another way to apprehend Neutral Flow would be the ending of an Iyengar Yoga class--Ṥavasᾱsana, the corpse pose, which according to B.K.S. Iyengar, is the most difficult pose to master but can be the most refreshing of all.  In his book, Light on Prᾱnᾱyᾱma, Mr. Iyengar provided immensely detailed instructions, with photographs of himself, so that we have landmarks and signposts to practice Ṥavasᾱsana as the culmination of vigorous asanas.  Because it involves so little Effort, and replicates Neutral Flow, Ṥavasᾱsana has allowed me to experience the ebb and flow of tension and where it is concentrated; it seems similar to the aristocratic, resting composure that Carlos engages in during his moments of stillness, anticipating an audience with the Sun King.

Whenever I feel the tension dissipating, nearly gone, I enter the subjunctive state of trailing away and returning elliptically inside a poem by the American poet and dance critic, Edwin Denby.  I glide into Denby’s impressions of New York City commotion and panoramas as the familiar timing of falling asleep, upstairs perhaps.  How pleasant to lie back and mentally snap my fingers at the great pronouncement--I think, I am—to Denby’s poem “Standing on the Streetcorner”, a very hushed and private paean by someone who just realized the connection between himself and humanity is only one more dynamic confluence of shifting, urban perspectives.

Any movement analysis includes that statement—I think, therefore I am—originally argued by the French Baroque mathematician and philosopher René Descartes in his eloquent essay “Of the Principles of Human Knowledge”.  Yet we must carefully consider Mr. Iyengar’s proposition in his book, The Tree of Yoga, that the dance is directed to the world outside one’s inner being while yoga’s “tremendous” implications lie within one’s inner being.  It is true that the asanas do not propel our bodies across the dance floor; they are a confluence of small movements by body parts fitted together into spiritually determined shapes which test our understanding of where we are in life.  It is almost the same thing every time we stand at the barre and go through our warm-up routines; we are asking ourselves if it is the mind controlling the body, if they are two distinct things, if it is the body shaping the mind.

Carlos reminds me that we can simply rely upon our dancing, our years of experiencing kinesthestic connectivity, then tap into the psychological effect it has wrought upon our bodies—serenity and connectivity; simply performing the movements tells us how much more delving into the physical sensations and analyzing is needed to attain the artistic quality we desire; performing the movements also reminds us of the goodly sum of lessons learned through observation, practice, and immersion in the dramatic role.  In other words, we should use our malleable minds to support our dancing bodies.  We should inhale acquiescence to exhale the performing art.  We should, as Carlos has learned in aristocratic fencing classes, find the proper mindset for the physical art.

As we enjoy the alchemy of combining different worlds, different heritages and civilizations, the convergence of the East and the West, we are calmed by the tempering effect of Neutral Flow upon the magnificently conscious drive to create.  BALAM likes Promethean power coming forth from our innermost being, but there is this other problem--dancing the role of Lord Hanuman who is the mischievous problem-solver in the Ramayana epic and the inspiration for the Balinese Kecak dance…He who is as swift as the wind and the human mind, He who subjugates Himself to Lord Rama…Geeta Iyengar reminds us to think of Lord Hanuman as one who has mastered perception and bodily senses, to remember how His name invokes the Protector Lord Vishnu (ha) and the Destroyer Lord Shiva (nu) and the Creator Lord Brahma (ma).  Prashant Iyengar cites Patanjali as he reminds us to aspire to perform the asana with decreasing prayatna (effort) and increasing saithilya (effortlessness), to fully sense ourselves going into the asana, staying within it, and coming out of the asana. [Yoga Rahasya, vol. 11, no. 2, 2004]

I would also think of it this way—sleep and inactivity allow for a blurring of movement boundaries.  The subliminal is our staging ground.   Then when we push off from the self-readying stillness, we start sharpening the boundary edges between the inner being and the world outside.  By dancing through whatever boundary edges--between ourselves and our present worlds or between our inner beings and our distant muses--we acquire a body-consciousness, a sensation of being different from that slight moment ago (or that one we just shed after an eternity of self-improvement).  For Carlos, Neutral Flow is the dancer’s gateway for emerging, coming into being.  Certainly, we will inhale stillness to exhale our movements whenever we rely on Neutral Flow to provide for resting, for self-composure, for letting the artistry come of itself and into its own. 

This photograph is part of Andreas Rentsch’s portfolio of subliminal motion captured on Polaroid film.  His stunning array of portfolios is best seen on http://rentschphoto.com/about/ where they are complemented by his life story.  Andreas has been exhibited or collected by Belgium’s Musée de la Photographie in Charleroi , Switzerland’s Musée de l’Elysée in Lausanne, the Museum of Fine Arts in Houston TX, Chrysler Museum of Art in Norfolk VA, the Heckscher Museum of Art in Huntington NY.  A native of Switzerland, he now resides in the USA and has taught photography at Stony Brook University, St. John’s University, the International Center of Photography and Lycoming College.